37 Comments

Rosie is a hero and shows real courage, facing deep misogyny every day, from men that profess to be women.

Expand full comment

I love you two, thank you for sharing your conversation on this matter. Disgusting creep was allowed to fool the public and so did it in plain sight!

When karma and justice find abusive men, my only wish is that they are at the height of their success, and have the world to lose.

Expand full comment

Shame it took so long.

Expand full comment

Yes and .... Better late than never!

Full Documentary on Russell Brand: In Plain Sight | A Channel 4 Dispatches Special https://youtu.be/XlxI979CnWQ

My wish is that the media industry and RB take up active feminist roles to replace the dehumanizing of patriarchy with the humanizing of feminism.

Expand full comment

Don't you find the younger generation less concerned with feminism and more concerned with other kinds of equality, it's a battle

Expand full comment

Agreed Kate. The promotion of identity politics is strewn w problems: Debate: Identity Politics is Tearing Society Apart https://youtu.be/hVMYfuzhbxk

The Right's Identity Politics Is More Dangerous Than the Left's. A renewed commitment to pluralism is its only cure. https://reason.com/2019/03/17/why-the-rights-identity-politics-is-more

How Identity Politics Has Divided The Left https://theintercept.com/2018/05/27/identity-politics-book-asad-haider/

Expand full comment

Thanks for the links, Brian. Appreciated.

Expand full comment

Right!

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

He never stopped bragging of his crimes against women. He's deleting his incriminating podcasts, shows - thank fook for books!

Expand full comment

Andrew Tate hired a very large staff to scrub the internet of all his crime bragging and is doing the right wing media PR rounds talking about "God and family" on the advice of his lawyers. Brand knew this was coming years ago and so he purposely started YouTube shows with the theme of "don't trust mainstream media" so that the day all this became public news he could tell his huge viewership "remember now, we don't trust the mainstream media".

Expand full comment

If you've any links exposing those scrubbing / grooming YT audience re distrusting msm would be great.

Link to share: Full Documentary on Russell Brand: In Plain Sight | A Channel 4 Dispatches Special https://youtu.be/XlxI979CnWQ

My wish is that the media industry and RB take up active feminist roles to replace the dehumanizing of patriarchy with the humanizing of feminism.

Expand full comment

With regards to scrubbing I referred to Andrew Tate. Many of his incriminating videos and audios have disappeared.

As far as grooming an audience to not trust MSM, that's been Brand's MO and schtick for years. His entire "brand" is built around it. Anyway, in this Substack there's a video created back in March by someone who had a feeling this would happen and predicted what Brand's reaction to it would be.

"I made this video in March when I was bored waiting for the story to land. I added the short clip from his YouTube statement at the weekend. It doesn’t take a genius to see the groundwork being laid. He’s known this story was coming for a long time. In his own words, “I’m aware of news media making phone calls, sending letters to people I know for ages and ages…”

So here’s what I predicted he’d say, because, like I said, it doesn’t take a genius.""

https://juliaraeside.substack.com/p/the-assassination-of-russell-brand

Expand full comment

Fantastic, both brilliant women any sane woman would want on their side, unfortunately although Labour may be slightly less bad on some issues than the Tories, I can't vote for them or be a member they have lost me due to their rampant misogyny

Expand full comment

The dudebros are spreading the message all over the internet that this is a conspiracy to frame Brand in order to "shut down his controversial views." What are they even? I tried listening to him and it didn't make a whole lot of sense. Neither did it seem particularly surprising or shocking.

Expand full comment

This is such a great conversation. I appreciate you and your work so much Julie Bindel and Rosie is remarkable speaking out in the current culture of the Labour party, she is one beacon of light still there for women. I saw the intimidation from Lloyd RM with horror, but it didn’t surprise me, I knew Lloyd very well in his late teens. I was his politics teacher for 2 years when he was a Liberal Democrat and obsessed with being an MP a careerist,

through and through and although mostly pleasant enough a couple of significant events when his behaviour was very disrespectful and aggressive in class and he was also very found of prolifically lying.

Expand full comment

Please stop calling Brand a lefty man!!! He is right wing and far right at that, just listern to his YouTube channel peddaling right wing conspiracy theories.

Expand full comment

He's all over the map, and does express anti corp, anti elite ie leftist views. How deep that goes into him is way dubious, given all his other horrid behaviors.

Expand full comment

Brand is no longer left wing if he ever was one. He pushes far right conspiracy theories. I used to watch his Youtube channel until he he started to descend further and further down the rabbit hole.

Expand full comment

How are RB's views far right? I find him very anti-elite, anti corp / anti govt abuse. That's very populist, which can swing left or right. Certainly his views on women were / likely still are given his denial ... are still mired in toxic patriarchy, and that's 100% far right ideology tho copied by nearly all libs and many leftists.

Thoughts?

Expand full comment

Please do it every week!!!

Expand full comment

excellent chat

Expand full comment

People who have come to his defense are folks like Elon Musk and Tucker Carlson.... since when are these people Left?? We must be living in alternate realities. But more importantly, when are you going to talk about why it seems like the majority of GC-sphere is defending Brand because right now it's looking like you're just evading talking about what we can all plainly see

Expand full comment
Sep 19, 2023·edited Sep 19, 2023

People who are coming to his defense are "people" with little respect for women. A lot of people seem to equate "left-wing" exclusively with "extreme nutjob", whereas the right wing has no short supply of its own surreal idiocy.

Expand full comment

Women are increasingly avoiding getting close to men, that's supposedly why there's a "male loneliness epidemic" that the media can't stop yapping about. I hope that domestic violence rates will plummet because of this "epidemic".

Andrew Tate hired a very large staff to scrub the internet of all his crime bragging and is doing the right wing media PR rounds talking about "God and family" on the advice of his lawyers. Brand knew this was coming years ago and so he purposely started YouTube shows with the theme of "don't trust mainstream media" so that the day all this became public news he could tell his huge viewership "remember now, we don't trust the mainstream media".

Expand full comment

Thank heavens for sane, intelligent, no nonsense women! You two are a credit to our sex. Well said and keep saying it.

Expand full comment
Sep 19, 2023·edited Sep 19, 2023

Thank you for nailing these so called lefty celebs where I hope it'll make a dent. As a feminist man I'll be sharing this early and often. On a related note .... I have been falsely accused of inappropriate behavior twice, which is why I believe Truth and Reconciliation Councils are the best and safest ways for accusers and accused to talk thru each others' versions of a given situation. Patriarchy is at the root of it and teaching boys and men to be feminists is the solution.

This does NOT mean not believing girls and women; but it DOES mean not excluding a boy or man from stating THEIR case. It has been wrong and damaging for men to silence / suppress the views of girls and women in such cases. I'm urging that we not make the reverse error by shutting out the views of boys or men, when they believe and have evidence that contradicts what they are accused of. THAT's where actual healing can happen. If violence- originating trauma is key to the case, it's vital to assure the abused party is not re-traumatized by using safer modes of communication like writing, shielding direct contact, using a surrogate etc.

Two related links: https://www.cacilawyer.com/the-role-of-parental-alienation-in-false-allegations-of-child.html

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/false-memory-syndrome

LOVE you Julie and share your work everywhere, sometimes to the dismay of so called leftist pro-trans colleagues.

Sincerely, Brian in Portland Oregon, u$a

Expand full comment

i liked russell brands books, and during covid in new zealand his channel felt like a life line but after covid i stopped watching. i like his exuberance and a kind of joyousness. however, i have always known he was a woman hater. a bigot. with russell the hate has always been easily apparent, self proclaimed, unashamed. no need to even scratch the surface.

Expand full comment

MINI ESSAY ON THE BIG PICTURE RE THE PREDATOR or WHISTLEBLOWER BRAND DEBACLE: The entertainment, legal, media etc institutions are rife bc they are built stone by stone with sexist and patriarchal norms. Consider these essential issues: 1) What is rape in terms of her/ RB's / and the law's perspective? 2) Despite real concerns about job security, if she said yes at the time she has no right to reconsider the issues of complicity, perp / victim roles? 3) How was it RB could both be an open booked predator AND be professionally rewarded for it? That’s three of dozens of related issues that are utterly biased and defined WITHIN the system of patriarchy.

These deeply subconscious and historically rooted gender norms throw up such thick fog as to leave us all feeling victimized, dehumanized and distrusting of the other sex. This is EXACTLY where elites WANT us to be and not evolve out of.

Patriarchy gives men a huge upper hand. It is therefore vital that men become activist feminists to support erasing the inequities patriarchy produces, if for no other cause than to reduce the risks of trauma that could hurt their female partners, kids and friends. To be complicit in a dehumanizing system is to dehumanize all: men AND women.

"If you're going to hold someone down you're going to have to hold on by the other end of the chain. You are confined by your own repression." Toni Morrison

Men Key to Ending Sexism https://goodmenproject.com/featured-content/men-we-can-do-better-kvnw/

Expand full comment

How Ch4 Doctored the Evidence Against Brand, which Tragically Weakens the Case Against Him https://www.youtube.com/live/nm7RwLWBTcw

Expand full comment