Discussion about this post

User's avatar
She Rites's avatar

These cases always take me back to November 2003 and the murder of a friend, Julia Pemberton and her son Will (my son's school friend) by her husband, his dad. (Fortunately, the older sister was away at university at the time). I was practicing as a midwife and had just attended a birth, calling my husband to say I was on the way home. He informed me of our friends' murders.

I'd known Julia as a 'school gate mum', but also, we played badminton together. Our boys were 15 and the school (that is the children there) were severely affected. As the news filtered out of the appalling circumstances of the murder, I wept often - not least for my son and his friends who had to experience this close loss - a boy, a friend, murdered by his own dad.

It is worth looking up the details as it is one of the worst cases of a woman being ignored - Julia had been warning the police for more than a year that her husband was threatening to kill her.

I was not a close friend, and so was shocked to learn that Julia, this well educated (ironically she was a Health Visitor who dealt professionally with 'domestic violence') financially well off, gentle woman had been abused by her husband for so long. That even with her knowledge and connections, she could not save herself. I am so glad that her brother Frank Mullane never let the police get away with the mishandling of this case - his work since to advocate for women like his sister is so important.

I often think of the daughter who was left...

Expand full comment
Jo Hands's avatar

Julie - you so clearly articulate what’s had me grinding my teeth about the reporting of this murder all week. The perpetual use of the word “tragic” alongside a seemingly happy family photo centering the killer.

It’s not a tragedy, he chose to murder his wife and daughter. The most selfish act a human can enact on another.

Those children falling through ice before Christmas, that’s a tragedy.

This was cold blooded murder that did not happen in a vacuum. As you say without scrutiny to the backstory of what was probably, as identified by Prof Jayne Monckton Smith a pattern of controlling behaviour, the public learn nothing. The dots are not joined up. These femicide killings and family annihilation murders are happening week in week out. But no, most times they are framed as isolated incidents and no wider risk to the public. (Mass shootings often start with domestic murder before the killer goes on a public rampage is a fact also rarely mentioned).

I have no idea as to the legality/due process of what will or will not be disclosed to the public about anything that happened or was known about their relationship prior to the shooting, but why can’t police or media outlets give a safety signposting message of where to go for help or reporting concerns about an individual or a situation you maybe worried about. Public awareness of what constitute coercive control and domestic abuse is still stuck in the 1970s in my experience.

Expand full comment
27 more comments...

No posts